The short version

The tax cost of reducing a company stock position depends mostly on three things: how much of the value has already been taxed (your basis), how long you have held the shares, and which tax year the sale lands in. Shares sold right at an RSU vest usually carry little extra tax. Long-held, low-basis shares carry the most.

Beyond simply selling, the main levers are spreading sales across tax years, pairing gains with losses, giving shares to charity or family, and, for some people, trusts or exchange funds. None of this tells you how much to hold. That is a personal risk decision. This article is about what each path costs in tax.

Why your job and your net worth share the same risk

When your salary, bonus, RSUs, options, and ESPP all come from one employer, a bad stretch for that company can hit your paycheck and your savings at the same time. That overlap is what people mean by a concentrated position.

A hypothetical: an engineer earns $300,000 a year and holds $1.5 million of her employer's stock, most of her net worth. If the company has a rough year, the share price could fall by half at the same time the company freezes hiring or cuts staff. She would lose a large piece of her savings in the same season her income becomes uncertain. Nothing about that requires the company to fail. It only requires the two risks to move together, which they tend to do.

I also understand why selling feels hard. You helped build the thing. The stock has been good to you. Selling can feel disloyal, or like betting against your own work, and the tax bill makes it easy to wait another quarter. Those feelings are normal, and they deserve a deliberate decision rather than a default.

To be clear about my role: how much company stock to keep, and what to do with any proceeds, is a personal risk decision you make with a financial advisor. My job is the tax cost of each path, so that whatever you decide, you are not surprised in April and you are not leaving an avoidable tax cost on the table.

What it costs to sell, by type of share

The tax on a sale is driven by your basis and your holding period, and those depend on how you got the shares.

  • RSUs sold at vest. The full vest value is already taxed as ordinary income on your W-2, and that value becomes your basis. Selling right away usually creates little additional gain or loss, so the extra tax is small. See how RSUs are taxed and how RSU cost basis works.
  • RSUs held after vest. Only the change since vesting is taxed when you sell. Held one year or less, that gain is short-term and taxed at ordinary rates. Held more than a year, it is long-term.
  • ESPP shares. Selling before you have held two years from the offering date and one year from the purchase date is a disqualifying disposition: the purchase discount is ordinary income and the rest is capital gain or loss. Meeting both periods makes it a qualifying disposition, where the ordinary piece is generally capped and more of the gain is long-term. Details are in my ESPP guide.
  • Stock options. Exercising and selling the same day turns the spread into ordinary income, but you walk away with cash and no additional stock. Exercising and holding keeps the position (and the concentration) and can, for ISOs, trigger AMT. Compare the two in NSOs vs ISOs and ISOs and AMT.

The holding period matters most federally. Short-term gains are taxed at ordinary rates up to 37%, while long-term gains are taxed at 0%, 15%, or 20%. High earners also pay the 3.8% net investment income tax (NIIT) on either kind once modified AGI passes $200,000 single or $250,000 married filing jointly. California and Oregon tax capital gains as ordinary income, so the holding period makes no difference at the state level.

That creates a real tradeoff. Waiting to cross the one-year mark can cut the federal rate on the gain by up to 17 percentage points. But during that wait you still hold the stock, and a price drop can easily cost more than the tax you were trying to save. I can show you the tax side of that trade in dollars. The risk side is yours to weigh.

Spreading sales across tax years

Selling a large block in one year stacks all of the gain on top of your salary, pushing more of it into the 20% federal bracket and higher state brackets. Splitting the same sales across two or three tax years can lower the total bill, sometimes meaningfully. It does not change the NIIT much for most tech earners, because wages alone usually put you over the threshold already.

Here is a simplified example. A married couple in California has about $400,000 of taxable income each year from wages. They hold company shares with $900,000 of long-term gain. I am assuming the 20% federal rate starts around $600,000 of taxable income and using approximate California brackets, the 1% California surcharge above $1 million, and no other changes. Real numbers will differ.

Approach Federal (incl. NIIT) California Total
All $900,000 in one year ~$204,000 ~$97,000 ~$301,000
$450,000 a year for two years ~$194,000 ~$86,000 ~$280,000
$300,000 a year for three years ~$184,000 ~$84,000 ~$268,000

In this illustration, spreading the sales saves roughly $20,000 to $33,000 in tax. The federal savings come from keeping more of the gain in the 15% bracket. The California savings come from staying out of the higher brackets and the surcharge. In Oregon, where the top 9.9% rate starts at a much lower income, spreading typically saves less at the state level.

The honest caveat: the savings assume the share price holds steady while you wait. A multi-year schedule keeps part of the position exposed for longer, and a decline in value can outweigh the tax difference. Tax law can also change between years. Spreading is a tool for managing the tax, not a reason by itself to hold longer than you otherwise would. If a move out of California is on the horizon, timing matters even more; see leaving California with equity comp.

Other ways to reduce a position without one big tax bill

Selling is not the only way to shrink a position. Each alternative below has tradeoffs, and some are irrevocable.

  • Pairing sales with tax-loss harvesting. Realized losses elsewhere in your taxable accounts offset gains from selling company stock, and unused losses carry forward. Watch the wash sale rule: selling company shares at a loss within 30 days of an RSU vest or ESPP purchase can disallow that loss. More in when equity loses value.
  • Donating appreciated shares. Giving shares held more than a year to a public charity or donor-advised fund can let you deduct the full market value and never pay tax on the gain. Deductions for appreciated stock are generally limited to 30% of AGI, with a five-year carryforward. See gifting appreciated stock.
  • Charitable remainder trusts. A CRT can sell contributed shares without immediate capital gains tax and pay you an income stream, with the remainder going to charity. The gain is recognized gradually as you receive payments, and the gift is irrevocable.
  • Gifting shares to family. A gift moves the shares, and your basis carries over to the recipient. If they are in a lower bracket, the eventual sale may be taxed less, though the kiddie tax limits this for many children and young adults. Shares given away also lose the basis step-up they could get at death. See gifting to heirs.
  • Exchange funds. These are private partnerships where many holders contribute different concentrated stocks and each receives an interest in the pooled portfolio. The contribution is generally not a taxable sale, and your original low basis carries over. They typically require holding for about seven years, are limited to accredited investors or qualified purchasers, charge ongoing fees, and may not accept every stock. I describe them so you know they exist, not as a recommendation.

One more: if your shares may qualify as qualified small business stock, the holding period can be worth a great deal. Selling before the required period can forfeit some or all of the federal exclusion, so check QSBS status before selling any early-stage founder or employee shares.

When you are not free to sell: windows, plans, and lockups

Even when you know what you want to do, the company may control when you can do it. Many employees can only trade during open trading windows, and insiders who regularly have access to confidential information often use a 10b5-1 plan, a pre-set selling schedule adopted while not in possession of material nonpublic information. Those plans come with cooling-off periods before the first trade, so the tax plan has to be built well ahead of the sales.

After an IPO, a lockup (commonly around 180 days) usually prevents any selling, even though RSU income may already be taxed. That means the first diversification decision often lands on a specific date, in a specific tax year, all at once. My IPO equity guide covers the IPO-year tax in more detail.

Where this trips people up

Letting the tax decide the risk

Avoiding a tax bill is a common reason people keep holding more than they meant to. The tax cost is real, but it is only one input.

Overestimating the tax on recent RSUs

People often assume selling recently vested RSUs triggers a large tax. Because the vest value is already your basis, the extra tax is often small. A brokerage form showing zero basis can make it look far worse than it is.

Triggering a wash sale by accident

Selling company stock at a loss within 30 days before or after a new RSU vest or ESPP purchase can disallow the loss.

Selling everything in December

A year-end rush stacks the whole gain into one tax year. Often, pushing part of the sales into January, when you were going to sell anyway, would have kept more of the gain in lower brackets.

Donating the wrong lots

For charitable gifts, the biggest benefit usually comes from long-term shares with the most appreciation. Giving short-term or high-basis shares generally limits the deduction and wastes the gain you could have avoided.

Concentrated stock tax questions people ask

How do I diversify my company stock tax-efficiently?

The tax-efficient paths usually involve selling the highest-basis or recently vested shares first, spreading larger sales across tax years, offsetting gains with harvested losses, and using appreciated shares for charitable giving. How much to diversify is a personal risk decision; the tax planning is about lowering the cost of whatever you decide.

Should I sell RSUs when they vest?

From a tax standpoint, selling at vest usually adds little additional tax, because the vest value is already taxed as income and becomes your basis. Whether to sell is a personal risk and financial planning decision, not a tax one.

How much tax will I pay selling company stock?

It depends on your gain (sale price minus basis), how long you held the shares, your other income, and your state. Long-term gains are taxed federally at 0%, 15%, or 20%, short-term gains at ordinary rates up to 37%, and high earners may add the 3.8% NIIT. California and Oregon tax both as ordinary income.

Is it worth waiting a year to get long-term capital gains?

It can cut the federal rate on the gain by up to 17 percentage points, but you keep the price risk while you wait, and a decline can outweigh the tax savings. State tax in California and Oregon is the same either way.

What are ways to reduce a concentrated stock position without a huge tax bill?

Common approaches include spreading sales across tax years, tax-loss harvesting, donating appreciated shares directly or through a donor-advised fund, charitable remainder trusts, gifting shares to family, and, for eligible investors, exchange funds. Each has tradeoffs, and some are irrevocable.

What is an exchange fund?

A private partnership where investors contribute different concentrated stocks and each receives an interest in the pooled portfolio, generally without a taxable sale at contribution. They typically require about a seven-year hold, are limited to accredited investors or qualified purchasers, and charge ongoing fees.

Keep reading

Want to see the tax cost before you decide?

I can model what different selling, giving, and timing choices would cost in tax, so you and your financial advisor are working from real numbers. If you are sitting on a large position and want that clarity, here is how to start a conversation.

Become a Client
Andrew Sedlacek, CPA

Andrew Sedlacek, CPA

Founder, OGCPA

Andrew is a Certified Public Accountant and the founder of OGCPA. He built his tax career at a local Bend firm and on Deloitte's tax team before founding the firm in 2019, and began professionally as a licensed financial advisor. He focuses on equity compensation, liquidity events, and the tax side of charitable giving and wealth distribution, and serves as the tax subject-matter expert for a venture-backed AI company. He works with clients across Bend, Oregon and the San Francisco Bay Area.

This article is general tax information, not tax or legal advice for your specific situation, and it is not investment advice. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security or to adopt any particular allocation; those decisions belong with you and a qualified financial advisor. The worked example is simplified and hypothetical, uses approximate rates, and is not a projection of your tax. Tax outcomes depend on your individual facts, and the rules change over time. Talk to a qualified professional before acting on anything here. Reading this page does not create a client relationship.