The short version
You often do. Employers usually withhold federal tax on RSU vests at a flat 22%, while many people with meaningful equity are in the 32% to 37% brackets. The gap shows up as a balance due in April, and if your total payments during the year fall short of a safe harbor, the IRS adds an underpayment penalty.
You avoid the federal penalty if your withholding and estimates cover at least 90% of this year's tax, or 100% of last year's (110% if last year's AGI was over $150,000). Extra W-2 withholding late in the year counts as if it were paid evenly all year, which makes it the best repair tool. California front-loads its schedule (30%, 40%, 0%, 30%) and takes away the prior-year safe harbor once your California AGI reaches $1 million.
Why RSU withholding usually falls short
RSU withholding falls short because the IRS lets employers treat vested shares as supplemental wages and withhold at a flat 22%, no matter what your actual bracket is. Only supplemental wages above $1 million in a calendar year get the mandatory 37% rate. Everything between is withheld at 22%, even when your marginal rate is 35%.
California works the same way at a different rate. Employers withhold 10.23% on stock option and bonus income, which is closer to the top California rates but can still be short for high earners, especially above $1 million where the extra 1% mental health services tax applies.
Two other events often come with no withholding at all:
- Selling shares after an IPO or in a tender. Capital gains on shares you already own are not wages, so nothing is withheld. A post-lockup sale can create a large bill with zero prepaid. I cover the broader picture in IPO equity taxes.
- Exercising ISOs and holding the shares. The spread is not wages for regular tax, but it can trigger alternative minimum tax. There is no withholding on it. See ISOs and AMT for how that is calculated.
The vest itself is covered in how RSUs are taxed. This page is about the payment side: how much you need to have paid, and by when, so the IRS and the state do not charge a penalty.
The federal safe harbors, including the 110% rule
You generally owe no federal underpayment penalty if your withholding plus estimated payments cover the smaller of two amounts: 90% of this year's total tax, or 100% of last year's total tax. If last year's AGI was over $150,000 ($75,000 if married filing separately), the prior-year number becomes 110%. There is also no penalty if you owe less than $1,000 after withholding and credits.
The prior-year safe harbor is the one most equity comp employees rely on, because you know the number in advance. It is the total tax line on last year's Form 1040. Multiply by 1.1, and that is your target for the full year, split into four equal installments.
Federal installments are due on these dates, moving to the next business day when one falls on a weekend or holiday:
| Installment | Due date | Federal share | California share |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | April 15 | 25% | 30% |
| 2nd | June 15 | 25% | 40% |
| 3rd | September 15 | 25% | 0% |
| 4th | January 15 (following year) | 25% | 30% |
The safe harbor protects you from the penalty, not from the tax. You can meet it and still owe a large balance in April. That is fine as long as you plan for the cash. These dates also sit alongside vesting and filing deadlines in my equity comp deadlines calendar.
A worked example: a $400,000 vest withheld at 22%
Here is how a big vest year plays out. The numbers are round and simplified, and they ignore Social Security, Medicare, and state tax to keep the focus on federal income tax.
Say you are single with a $300,000 salary. Last year your AGI was about $310,000 and your total federal tax was $70,000. This year, $400,000 of RSUs vest, bringing your income to about $700,000.
| Withholding on salary | $60,000 |
| Withholding on the vest ($400,000 × 22%) | $88,000 |
| Total withheld | $148,000 |
| Estimated actual federal income tax | about $210,000 |
| Balance due in April | about $62,000 |
| Prior-year safe harbor (110% × $70,000) | $77,000 |
In this first big year, withholding of $148,000 is well above the $77,000 safe harbor, so there is no federal penalty. There is still a $62,000 bill, and people are regularly surprised by it because they assumed withholding took care of everything.
The trap is the second big year. Next year, last year's tax is $210,000, so the prior-year safe harbor jumps to $231,000. If income and withholding look the same, $148,000 misses both that target and 90% of the current year (about $189,000). Now the shortfall is penalized, installment by installment. The year after a big vest or an IPO is when I see the most penalties.
How to fix a shortfall before year end
The most effective fix is extra W-2 withholding, because federal withholding is treated as paid evenly across the year unless you elect otherwise. Withholding added in December counts as if a quarter of it was paid by April 15, a quarter by June 15, and so on. That can cure a shortfall from earlier quarters after the fact.
Estimated payments work differently. They count on the date you make them. A payment in December only helps the January 15 installment and does nothing for a shortfall in April, June, or September. Paying late still stops the penalty from growing, so a late payment is better than no payment.
Practical ways to add withholding late in the year:
- Update your W-4. Enter an extra flat amount per paycheck on line 4(c) for the last few pay periods.
- Ask about a higher RSU withholding rate. Some stock plans let you elect a rate above 22% for vests. Whether that is available depends on your employer's plan.
- Use a late-year bonus. If one is coming, extra withholding from that check counts the same way.
If your income was lumpy, the annualized method can help. By default the IRS assumes you earned your income evenly and expects four equal installments. If a large vest or an IPO sale happened in November, that assumption overstates what you owed in April and June. Form 2210 Schedule AI (the annualized income installment method) measures each installment against the income you had actually received by then, which can shrink or eliminate the penalty for earlier quarters. It takes more work, but on a late-year liquidity event it is often worth it.
The penalty itself works like interest. It is calculated at the federal underpayment rate (the short-term federal rate plus 3 percentage points, reset each quarter) on each installment's shortfall, for the number of days it was late. It is not a flat fine, which is why paying sooner always helps. For the other items worth checking in the fall, see my year-end tax checklist.
California and Oregon estimated taxes
California estimated taxes are due on the same dates as federal, but in uneven amounts: 30% by April 15, 40% by June 15, nothing in September, and 30% by January 15. That means 70% of the year's estimate is due by mid-June, which catches people who plan only around the federal schedule.
California's safe harbors look similar to the federal ones: 90% of this year's tax, or 100% of last year's (110% if last year's California AGI was over $150,000, or $75,000 if married filing separately). The major difference is at the top. If your California AGI for the current year is $1 million or more ($500,000 if married filing separately), you cannot use the prior-year safe harbor at all. You have to pay in 90% of the current year's tax on the 30/40/0/30 schedule.
That rule matters most in an IPO or tender year. You may not know whether you will cross $1 million until late in the year, and by then the April and June installments have passed. California's penalty form, FTB 5805, has its own annualized method that can help when the income arrived late. If you are thinking about moving, leaving California with equity comp covers how the state sources that income.
Oregon also uses quarterly estimates on the same four dates as federal, and generally expects them if you will owe $1,000 or more after withholding and credits. Oregon has its own safe-harbor rules and penalty form (Form OR-10), and they do not match California's. If you live in Bend and your equity comes from a Bay Area employer, I check both states' rules each year, since state withholding can land in the wrong state after a move.
Where this trips people up
Assuming withholding means you are covered
A 22% flat rate on a vest is a deposit, not a calculation of your actual tax. If your bracket is higher, the difference is due in April.
Using last year's safe harbor after a big year
The prior-year target resets from whatever last year's tax was. After a large vest or IPO year, 110% of that number can be far more than your normal withholding.
Making a December estimated payment to fix April
Estimated payments count when made, so a December check does not cure earlier quarters. Extra W-2 withholding in December does, because it is spread across the year.
Missing California's June installment
California wants 70% of the year's estimate by June 15 and nothing in September. Paying on the federal 25% rhythm leaves you behind in the first half.
Forgetting sales and exercises with no withholding
Post-IPO share sales and ISO exercises that trigger AMT have nothing withheld. The tax on them has to come from estimates or extra withholding elsewhere.
Estimated tax questions people ask
Do I need to pay estimated taxes on RSUs?
Often, yes. Employers usually withhold federal tax on RSU vests at a flat 22%, which is below the bracket many equity comp employees are in. If withholding will not cover a safe harbor, you need estimated payments or extra withholding to avoid a penalty, and you may still owe a balance in April.
What is the 110% safe harbor?
It is the prior-year test for avoiding the federal underpayment penalty. Normally, paying in 100% of last year's total tax through withholding and estimates is enough. If last year's AGI was over $150,000 ($75,000 married filing separately), you need 110% of last year's tax instead.
How do I avoid an underpayment penalty after a big vest or IPO?
Pay in enough to meet a safe harbor: 90% of this year's tax or 100% (or 110%) of last year's. If you are short late in the year, add W-2 withholding, which counts as paid evenly all year. If the income came late in the year, the annualized method on Form 2210 Schedule AI can reduce the penalty.
When are California estimated taxes due?
California uses the federal dates but different amounts: 30% of the year's estimate by April 15, 40% by June 15, nothing in September, and 30% by January 15 of the following year. If your California AGI is $1 million or more ($500,000 married filing separately), you must base estimates on 90% of the current year's tax.
Does increasing my withholding in December fix earlier quarters?
For federal purposes, generally yes. W-2 withholding is treated as paid evenly throughout the year unless you elect otherwise, so extra withholding in December is spread back across all four installments. Estimated payments do not work that way; they count on the date you make them.
How much is the underpayment penalty?
It works like interest. The IRS applies the federal underpayment rate, which is the short-term federal rate plus 3 percentage points and resets each quarter, to each installment's shortfall for the number of days it was late. Paying sooner reduces it.
Keep reading
How RSUs are taxed
What happens at vesting and sale, and why the W-2 number matters. →
IPO equity taxes
The tax side of an IPO, from lockup to the first big sale. →
ISOs and AMT
How an ISO exercise can create tax with nothing withheld. →
Equity comp deadlines
The dates that matter across a year of vesting, exercising, and filing. →
Year-end tax checklist
What to review before December 31 if you hold equity comp. →
All resources
Browse every equity-comp explainer in one place. →
Big vest or liquidity event this year?
Projecting the year's tax, sizing estimated payments for federal and state, and timing extra withholding before December is routine work for me. If you have a large vest, an IPO, or a tender coming and want to know what you will owe and when, here is how to start a conversation.
Become a Client
Andrew Sedlacek, CPA
Founder, OGCPA
Andrew is a Certified Public Accountant and the founder of OGCPA. He built his tax career at a local Bend firm and on Deloitte's tax team before founding the firm in 2019, and began professionally as a licensed financial advisor. He focuses on equity compensation, liquidity events, and the tax side of charitable giving and wealth distribution, and serves as the tax subject-matter expert for a venture-backed AI company. He works with clients across Bend, Oregon and the San Francisco Bay Area.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice for your specific situation. Tax outcomes depend on your individual facts, and the rules change over time. Talk to a qualified professional (I am happy to be that person) before acting on anything here. Reading this page does not create a client relationship.