The short version

In an acquisition, your equity is usually cashed out, converted into the buyer's equity, or cancelled. Cash paid for options and RSUs is compensation, taxed as wages at ordinary rates. Cash paid for shares you already own is a sale, taxed as a capital gain, and long-term if you held the shares more than a year.

If you receive buyer stock in a deal structured as a tax-free reorganization, the tax on your shares is generally deferred until you sell the new shares, except for any cash you also receive. Escrow holdbacks and earnouts are often taxed when you actually receive them. The merger agreement and your award notices decide which of these applies to you.

What happens to vested and unvested stock options

Vested options are usually cashed out, converted into options on the buyer's stock, or cancelled if they are underwater. Unvested options are usually converted, accelerated, or cancelled. The merger agreement sets the treatment for everyone, and your plan documents and award notice say what the company is allowed to do.

  • Cashed out. You receive the spread (deal price minus your strike price) in cash, with no exercise needed. For NSOs, that payment is wages: it goes on your W-2 with income tax withholding, Social Security, and Medicare.
  • ISOs that are cashed out lose their ISO treatment. A cash payment for cancelling an ISO is generally taxed as ordinary compensation, not capital gain. If you exercise ISOs and your shares are bought in the deal before you meet the holding periods (two years from grant, one year from exercise), that sale is a disqualifying disposition, which also produces ordinary income. Either way, the favorable ISO rate is gone for that portion. I explain the two option types in NSOs vs ISOs.
  • Assumed or converted. Your options become options on the buyer's stock, with the share count and strike adjusted by the exchange ratio. Done correctly, the conversion is not a taxable event, and ISOs can keep ISO status. You are taxed later, when you exercise the new options.
  • Cancelled. Options with a strike price above the deal price are often cancelled for nothing. There is no tax, and because you never paid anything for an unexercised option, there is also no deductible loss.

Unvested awards follow the vesting terms. Single-trigger acceleration vests awards at closing. Double-trigger acceleration requires a second event, usually a termination without cause or resignation for good reason within a set window after the deal. If nothing accelerates, unvested awards are typically converted into buyer awards on the same schedule, or cancelled if the agreement allows it.

Are acquisition cash-outs taxed as income or capital gains?

It depends on what is being bought. Cash paid for options and RSUs is ordinary income taxed as wages. Cash paid for shares you already own is a capital gain or loss.

RSUs. RSUs cashed out at closing, or accelerated and settled, are wages equal to the amount you receive, taxed the same way as a normal vest. RSUs converted into buyer RSUs are not taxed until they vest.

Shares you own. In a cash deal, selling your shares is a taxable sale. Your gain is the price received minus your basis. Your basis is what you paid plus any amount already taxed as compensation, such as the NSO spread at exercise. Held more than a year, the gain is long-term. ISO shares sold before the holding periods are met become a disqualifying disposition. If you paid AMT when you exercised ISOs, the sale can also free up an AMT credit, covered in ISOs and AMT.

For restricted stock, if you filed an 83(b) election, the shares were taxed when granted, your holding period started then, and the deal proceeds are generally capital gain even if the shares were technically unvested. Without an 83(b), unvested restricted stock that accelerates at closing is wages at that point.

What is a stock-for-stock rollover?

A stock-for-stock rollover is when you exchange shares of your company for shares of the buyer. If the deal qualifies as a tax-free reorganization under Section 368, you generally owe no tax on the exchange. Not every stock deal qualifies, so check the deal documents.

In a qualifying reorganization, the gain is deferred, not forgiven. Your old basis carries over into the new shares, and your old holding period carries over too. The tax comes due when you eventually sell the buyer's shares.

Mixed consideration. Many deals pay part cash and part stock. The cash (called "boot") is generally taxable up to the amount of your gain on those shares. It is usually capital gain, though in some cases boot can be treated as a dividend. Some deals let you elect how much cash versus stock you receive, subject to proration.

If you hold qualified small business stock, a qualifying reorganization can carry QSBS status into the buyer shares, but generally only for the gain built up as of the exchange. If you sell QSBS for cash, Section 1045 may let you defer the gain by reinvesting in other QSBS within 60 days, if you held the original stock more than six months.

How are escrow and earnouts taxed?

For shares you sell, escrow holdbacks and earnouts are generally taxed when you receive them, under the installment method, rather than all in the closing year.

Under the installment method, each payment carries a proportional share of your basis and gain. If the escrow is never released, you report less gain. If an earnout's total is uncertain, special contingent-payment rules decide how basis is spread across years. A portion of a payment received well after closing may be treated as interest. You can elect out of the installment method and report everything in the closing year, which occasionally makes sense. Sales of publicly traded stock are not eligible, so this matters most when a private company is acquired.

For option and RSU holders, amounts held back from your cash-out are wages when paid to you, subject to payroll withholding at that time. Deferred compensation rules limit how long these payments can be stretched, so the agreement usually sets a fixed payment window.

A worked example

Here is a simplified example with round, illustrative numbers. Say you work at a private startup that is acquired in an all-cash deal at $10 per share, with 10% of the shareholder price held in escrow for 18 months. You have:

  • 10,000 shares you got by exercising NSOs three years ago. Your basis is $2 per share (strike plus the spread taxed at exercise), or $20,000.
  • 20,000 vested NSOs with a $2 strike, cashed out at closing.
  • 8,000 unvested RSUs, converted into buyer RSUs on the same vesting schedule.
Item Amount Tax treatment
Shares: cash at closing (90%) $90,000 $72,000 long-term gain
Shares: escrow released later (10%) $10,000 $8,000 long-term gain, when received
Vested NSOs: 20,000 × ($10 − $2) $160,000 Wages on your W-2
Unvested RSUs, converted $0 now Wages as they vest

The $80,000 total gain on the shares is 80% of the $100,000 price, so each dollar received carries 80 cents of gain. The option cash-out is the bigger tax item. Federal withholding on it is often at the 22% supplemental rate, or $35,200. If your marginal rate is 35%, the federal tax is about $56,000, leaving roughly $20,800 unpaid, plus state tax. The share sale has no withholding at all.

Now change one fact: the same $100,000 for your 10,000 shares is paid as $80,000 of buyer stock plus $20,000 of cash, in a qualifying reorganization. You recognize $20,000 of gain (the cash, since it is less than your $80,000 total gain). The other $60,000 of gain is deferred, and your $20,000 basis carries into the buyer shares.

Golden parachutes and planning before closing

Most employees will not run into the golden parachute rules, but executives and large holders should check. Under Section 280G, if deal-related payments to certain officers, larger shareholders, and highly paid individuals reach three times their average pay from the prior five years, the amount above one times that average is an "excess parachute payment." The individual owes a 20% excise tax on the excess, on top of regular income tax, and the company loses its deduction. Private companies can often avoid this with a shareholder approval vote.

For everyone else, the planning is mostly about reading carefully and running numbers before the money arrives:

  • Read the merger agreement summary and your award notices to learn which outcome applies to each grant, and whether any acceleration is single or double trigger.
  • If you are offered a cash versus stock election, model the tax on each choice. The investment decision about holding buyer stock is a personal one to make with a financial advisor.
  • If you receive buyer shares, know your basis and holding period for each lot, since the tax on any later sale depends on them. Public company shares also bring trading windows, as after an IPO.
  • Plan estimated tax payments for the gap between withholding and your actual tax, and for the share sale that had none.

Where this trips people up

Assuming it is all capital gain

People often expect the whole payout to be taxed at capital gain rates. Cash for options and RSUs is wages. Only shares you already owned produce capital gain.

Counting on withholding to cover it

Flat supplemental withholding on a large option cash-out often falls short of your real rate, and share sale proceeds have no withholding. The bill arrives in April, sometimes with an underpayment penalty.

Reporting escrow gain in the wrong year

Gain on escrow and earnout payments usually belongs in the year you receive them, and forgotten escrow releases are easy to miss.

Losing track of carryover basis

After a stock-for-stock deal, the buyer's broker may show a basis based on the deal price rather than your old basis. The number that matters is your carryover basis, and getting it wrong changes your gain when you sell.

Missing the AMT credit on ISO shares

If you paid AMT when you exercised ISOs, selling those shares in the deal can let you recover some of it through the AMT credit. It is not automatic. You have to track it and claim it.

Acquisition equity questions people ask

What happens to my stock options when my company is acquired?

Vested options are usually cashed out for the spread, converted into options on the buyer's stock, or cancelled if underwater. Unvested options are usually converted, accelerated, or cancelled. The merger agreement and your award notice decide which applies.

Are acquisition cash-outs taxed as income or capital gains?

Cash for options and RSUs is ordinary income taxed as wages. Cash for shares you already own is a capital gain, long-term if you held the shares more than a year.

What is a stock-for-stock rollover?

It is an exchange of your company's shares for the buyer's shares. If the deal qualifies as a tax-free reorganization, gain is generally deferred, and your basis and holding period carry over. Any cash you also receive is generally taxable.

How are escrow and earnouts taxed?

For shares you sell, escrow and earnout payments are often reported under the installment method, so gain is taxed when you receive the money. For options and RSUs, deferred amounts are wages when paid.

Do my ISOs keep their tax benefits in an acquisition?

Only if they are assumed or converted in a way that preserves ISO status. ISOs cashed out, or ISO shares sold in the deal before the holding periods are met, produce ordinary income instead of long-term capital gain.

Does my QSBS survive an acquisition?

In a qualifying stock-for-stock reorganization, QSBS status can carry over to the buyer shares, generally limited to the gain as of the exchange. In a cash sale, Section 1045 may allow deferral if you reinvest in other QSBS within 60 days.

Keep reading

Is your company being acquired?

Sorting out how each grant is treated, projecting the tax on the payout, and planning estimated payments before the money lands is routine work for me. If you have a deal closing or just closed, here is how to start a conversation.

Become a Client
Andrew Sedlacek, CPA

Andrew Sedlacek, CPA

Founder, OGCPA

Andrew is a Certified Public Accountant and the founder of OGCPA. He built his tax career at a local Bend firm and on Deloitte's tax team before founding the firm in 2019, and began professionally as a licensed financial advisor. He focuses on equity compensation, liquidity events, and the tax side of charitable giving and wealth distribution, and serves as the tax subject-matter expert for a venture-backed AI company. He works with clients across Bend, Oregon and the San Francisco Bay Area.

This article is general information, not tax or legal advice for your specific situation. Tax outcomes depend on your individual facts, and the rules change over time. Talk to a qualified professional (I am happy to be that person) before acting on anything here. Reading this page does not create a client relationship.